{"agency":{"id":"charm-city-circulator","name":"Charm City Circulator","subdivision_code":"US-MD","subdivision_name":"Maryland"},"categories":{"completeness":{"details":{"accessibility":{"measures":"presence_not_usability","score":62.5,"stops_marked_accessible_pct":100.0,"stops_marked_not_accessible_pct":0.0,"stops_stated_pct":100.0,"trips_stated_pct":0.0},"accessibility_measures":"presence_not_usability","cemv":{"declared":false,"supported":false},"components":{"contact":7.5,"fares":0.0,"headsigns":7.4,"stop_names":15.0,"wheelchair_stops":25.0,"wheelchair_trips":0.0},"fare_free":false,"fares":{"applied":false,"has_leg_rules":false,"has_products":false,"has_transfer_rules":false,"model":"none","product_count":0},"flex":{"booking_reachable":false,"booking_rule_count":0,"has_booking_rules":false,"has_flex":false},"has_fares":false,"headsign_applicable_trips":556,"headsign_loop_exempt_trips":540,"headsign_pct":0.0,"headsign_scored_pct":49.3,"headsign_stop_headsign_trips":0,"mixed_case_stop_name_pct":100.0,"pathways":{"has_entrances":false,"has_levels":false,"has_pathways":false,"has_stations":false,"has_step_free":false,"pathway_count":0},"stops":106,"translations":{"feed_lang":"en","has_translations":false,"languages":[],"translated_tables":[],"translation_count":0},"trips":1096,"unmeasured_components":[],"wheelchair_accessible_pct":0.0,"wheelchair_boarding_pct":100.0,"wheelchair_marked_accessible_pct":100.0,"wheelchair_marked_not_accessible_pct":0.0},"findings":[{"code":"scorecard_wheelchair_accessible_unknown","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"scorecard_wheelchair_accessible_unknown","line":"Fixing this covers all 1,096 trips in the feed.","reach":{"affected":1096,"basis":"trips","basis_label":"trips","reason":"","share":1.0,"total":1096,"total_source":"routability.trips_total"},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":1096,"effort":"A default or per-trip field in your export.","fix":"Set wheelchair_accessible on every trip. If every vehicle is accessible, this may be one default; otherwise use the value for each trip.","owner":"Likely your export tool","points":15.0,"severity":"WARNING","what":"1096 of 1096 trips don't say whether the vehicle is wheelchair accessible.","why":"Even with accessible stops, riders need to know the bus itself can take them."},{"code":"scorecard_no_fare_data","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"scorecard_no_fare_data","line":"This one is about the feed as a whole, so there is no share of it to count.","reach":{"affected":null,"basis":"none","basis_label":null,"reason":"feed_level","share":null,"total":null,"total_source":null},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":1,"effort":"A small file for most flat-fare systems.","fix":"Add fare_attributes.txt (or Fares v2 files) with your fare structure. If your service is fare-free, ask to have it marked fare-free instead.","owner":"","points":15.0,"severity":"WARNING","what":"The feed contains no fare information.","why":"Riders see 'fare unknown' in trip planners and can't budget their trip; visitors are most affected."},{"code":"scorecard_missing_headsigns","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"scorecard_missing_headsigns","line":"Fixing this covers 556 of 1,096 trips, about 51% of them.","reach":{"affected":556,"basis":"trips","basis_label":"trips","reason":"","share":0.5073,"total":1096,"total_source":"routability.trips_total"},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":556,"effort":"Usually one value per route pattern in your scheduling source.","fix":"Add the destination, direction, or 'via' label riders actually see to trip_headsign. Do not copy the route name. If the label changes during the trip, use stop_headsign.","owner":"","points":7.6,"severity":"WARNING","what":"556 of 1096 trips have no headsign, the text that tells riders where the bus is going. A trip counts when it has trip_headsign or a stop_headsign at every stop.","why":"When a route has multiple directions or patterns, the route name alone may not tell riders which service is coming."},{"code":"scorecard_no_feed_contact","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"scorecard_no_feed_contact","line":"This one is about the feed as a whole, so there is no share of it to count.","reach":{"affected":null,"basis":"none","basis_label":null,"reason":"feed_level","share":null,"total":null,"total_source":null},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":1,"effort":"One field.","fix":"Add feed_contact_email to feed_info.txt.","owner":"","points":7.5,"severity":"INFO","what":"feed_info.txt has no technical contact (feed_contact_email or feed_contact_url).","why":"App makers and state data programs have nobody to email when they spot a problem. Small errors then sit in the feed for months."}],"name":"completeness","score":54.9,"status":"measured","summary":"100% of stops state wheelchair accessibility (100% marked accessible, 0% marked not accessible). This measures what the feed publishes, not whether a stop is physically usable. Fare data is not published.","weight":0.25},"correctness":{"details":{"distinct_codes":6,"instances_by_severity":{"ERROR":0,"INFO":1,"WARNING":12},"validator_version":"8.0.1"},"findings":[{"code":"missing_recommended_field","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"missing_recommended_field","line":"This is a validator notice, and the validator decides what each instance covers, so no share of the network can be read from it here.","reach":{"affected":null,"basis":"none","basis_label":null,"reason":"validator_notice","share":null,"total":null,"total_source":null},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":5,"effort":"A field at a time; not urgent.","fix":"Review the flagged fields and fill in the ones your riders would use.","owner":"","points":4.0,"severity":"WARNING","what":"Some files leave out fields that GTFS asks for but does not require.","why":"Recommended fields like agency_phone or stop descriptions make the feed more useful to riders and trip planners."},{"code":"expired_calendar","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"expired_calendar","line":"This is a validator notice, and the validator decides what each instance covers, so no share of the network can be read from it here.","reach":{"affected":null,"basis":"none","basis_label":null,"reason":"validator_notice","share":null,"total":null,"total_source":null},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":4,"effort":"One setting in most export tools.","fix":"Remove past service periods the next time you export the feed.","owner":"Likely your export tool","points":4.0,"severity":"WARNING","what":"Some service calendars in the feed have already ended.","why":"Expired calendars are dead weight and can hide real schedule problems from your staff and vendors."},{"code":"missing_feed_contact_email_and_url","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"missing_feed_contact_email_and_url","line":"This is a validator notice, and the validator decides what each instance covers, so no share of the network can be read from it here.","reach":{"affected":null,"basis":"none","basis_label":null,"reason":"validator_notice","share":null,"total":null,"total_source":null},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":1,"effort":"One field, set once in export settings.","fix":"Add feed_contact_email or feed_contact_url to feed_info.txt.","owner":"Likely your export tool","points":4.0,"severity":"WARNING","what":"feed_info.txt lists no contact email and no contact URL.","why":"Without a contact, apps like Google Maps can't reach you when they find a problem in the feed."},{"code":"missing_feed_info_date","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"missing_feed_info_date","line":"This is a validator notice, and the validator decides what each instance covers, so no share of the network can be read from it here.","reach":{"affected":null,"basis":"none","basis_label":null,"reason":"validator_notice","share":null,"total":null,"total_source":null},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":1,"effort":"Two fields, likely set once in your export settings.","fix":"Fill in feed_start_date and feed_end_date in feed_info.txt.","owner":"Likely your export tool","points":4.0,"severity":"WARNING","what":"feed_info.txt does not state when this feed starts and ends.","why":"Without stated dates, apps can't warn anyone before your data goes stale; it just disappears one day."},{"code":"trip_coverage_not_active_for_next7_days","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"trip_coverage_not_active_for_next7_days","line":"This is a validator notice, and the validator decides what each instance covers, so no share of the network can be read from it here.","reach":{"affected":null,"basis":"none","basis_label":null,"reason":"validator_notice","share":null,"total":null,"total_source":null},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":1,"effort":"One setting in most export tools.","fix":"Trim past service periods the next time you export.","owner":"Likely your export tool","points":4.0,"severity":"WARNING","what":"Many of the feed's trips don't run at all in the next 7 days.","why":"It usually means old service periods are still in the export, making the feed bigger and harder to check."},{"code":"unknown_column","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"unknown_column","line":"This is a validator notice, and the validator decides what each instance covers, so no share of the network can be read from it here.","reach":{"affected":null,"basis":"none","basis_label":null,"reason":"validator_notice","share":null,"total":null,"total_source":null},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":1,"effort":"A quick look at the flagged files.","fix":"Check the flagged column names for misspellings of standard GTFS fields; remove them if they are vendor extras.","owner":"","points":0.5,"severity":"INFO","what":"Some files contain columns that are not part of the GTFS spec.","why":"Harmless to riders, but apps ignore these columns and they can hide typos in real column names."}],"name":"correctness","score":79.5,"status":"measured","summary":"The MobilityData validator flagged 6 kinds of issue across 13 instances (0 error, 12 warning, 1 informational).","weight":0.35},"freshness":{"details":{"days_until_expiry":-1727,"effective_expiry_date":"2022-02-28","expiry_limited_by":"service_calendar","feed_end_date":null,"feed_start_date":"2020-08-19","feed_version":"20201006","has_feed_info":true,"last_service_date":"2022-02-28","seasonal_boundary":false,"service_horizon_review_years":10,"service_horizon_status":"within_review_threshold","service_type":"fixed"},"findings":[{"code":"scorecard_feed_expired","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"scorecard_feed_expired","line":"This one is about the feed as a whole, so there is no share of it to count.","reach":{"affected":null,"basis":"none","basis_label":null,"reason":"feed_level","share":null,"total":null,"total_source":null},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":1,"effort":"Usually one export setting; export on a schedule so it never lapses again.","fix":"Re-export the feed with a calendar that reaches further out. Set feed_end_date in feed_info.txt past your next service change.","owner":"Likely your export tool","points":100.0,"severity":"ERROR","what":"Service data ended 1727 day(s) ago.","why":"When the calendar runs out, trip planners stop showing this agency even though the buses are still running. Riders are told the service does not exist."},{"code":"scorecard_missing_feed_info_dates","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"scorecard_missing_feed_info_dates","line":"This one is about the feed as a whole, so there is no share of it to count.","reach":{"affected":null,"basis":"none","basis_label":null,"reason":"feed_level","share":null,"total":null,"total_source":null},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":1,"effort":"Two fields, set once in export settings.","fix":"Add feed_info.txt with feed_start_date and feed_end_date to your export.","owner":"Likely your export tool","points":15.0,"severity":"WARNING","what":"feed_info.txt is missing its start/end dates","why":"Apps and this scorecard can't warn anyone before the feed goes stale without stated validity dates."}],"name":"freshness","score":0.0,"status":"measured","summary":"Service data ended 1727 day(s) ago. Trip planners have likely already dropped this feed.","weight":0.2},"realtime":{"name":"realtime","status":"not_yet_measured","summary":"Not scored yet. Nothing here counts against the grade.","weight":0.2}},"confidence":{"feed_age_days":0,"fetch_source":"origin","level":"medium","measured_categories":3,"notes":["Realtime quality was not measured this run. It does not count against the grade.","The feed was downloaded from the configured feed URL. Publisher ownership of that URL is not verified."],"rt_windows":0,"total_categories":4},"conformance":{"awarded":false,"criteria":[{"detail":"Passes validation with no errors.","key":"valid","met":true},{"detail":"Service data expired 1727 days ago.","key":"current","met":false},{"detail":"States wheelchair access on 100% of stops and 0% of trips; the mark needs 90% of each.","key":"accessible","met":false}],"status":"not_yet","summary":"Two requirements remain for this feed to earn the conformance mark. Service data expired 1727 days ago. States wheelchair access on 100% of stops and 0% of trips; the mark needs 90% of each.","version":2},"feed":{"license_note":"No stated data license in the Mobility Database; verify before publishing.","reachable":true,"sha256":"9f637611439af3b27674ad1d187d0e7e16adc18b75595b8c648a2a9352c4622c","size_bytes":215703,"source_provenance":"unverified","static_url":"https://github.com/mobilityequity/maryland-local-gtfs/raw/master/CCC_GTFS.zip"},"fetch":{"final_url":"https://raw.githubusercontent.com/mobilityequity/maryland-local-gtfs/master/CCC_GTFS.zip","max_attempts":4,"reader_archive_profile":"raw-v1","source":"origin","user_agent":"gtfs-scorecard/1.5.1 (+https://gtfsscorecard.org)"},"generated_at":"2026-11-09T00:00:00+00:00","geo":{"bbox":[-76.63495,39.2659,-76.58415,39.32803],"lat":39.28776,"lon":-76.6128,"stop_count":106},"mode_profile":{"ferry_only":false,"graded":false,"has_ferry":false,"is_multimodal":false,"measured":true,"modes":[{"key":"bus","label":"Bus","route_count":4,"trip_count":1096,"trip_share_pct":100.0}],"primary_mode":"bus","primary_mode_label":"Bus","route_count":4,"trip_count":1096},"ntd_id_alignment":{"detail":"This feed provides agency_id. For RY2026, keep one stable value for each NTD reporter represented in the feed and crosswalk it on the P-50 form. The value does not need to equal the five-digit NTD ID; we do not have that ID on file, so the optional equality comparison is not checked yet.","feed_agency_ids":["CCC"],"status":"unknown"},"ntd_readiness":{"pillars":[{"detail":"Published at a public URL.","key":"published","status":"ready"},{"detail":"Passes validation with no errors.","key":"valid","status":"ready"},{"detail":"Service data expired 1727 days ago, so FTA would find the link out of date.","key":"current","status":"not_ready"},{"detail":"agency.txt provides agency_id. For RY2026, keep one stable value for each NTD reporter represented in the feed and crosswalk each value on the P-50 form.","key":"agency_id","status":"ready"}],"status":"not_ready","summary":"Resolve this before you certify on the D-10. Service data expired 1727 days ago, so FTA would find the link out of date."},"overall":{"grade":"F","margin_to_lower_band":51.9,"margin_to_next_band":8.1,"score":51.9},"recommendations":[{"category":"accessibility","code":"scorecard_route_color_low_contrast","count":2,"effort":"A per-route color setting in your scheduling software.","fix":"Adjust route_color or route_text_color so each pair clears 4.5:1. Often switching the text between black and white is enough.","owner":"Likely your export tool","points":0.0,"severity":"WARNING","what":"2 route badge(s) pair a color and text color below the WCAG 4.5:1 contrast bar (Orange, Green).","why":"Riders with low vision struggle to read a low-contrast route badge. It also washes out on a phone screen in sunlight at the stop."},{"category":"accessibility","code":"scorecard_stop_name_needs_tts","count":6,"effort":"A short text field per affected stop; start with the busiest.","fix":"Add tts_stop_name with the spoken form, e.g. 'Main Street and Second Avenue', for the affected stops.","owner":"","points":0.0,"severity":"INFO","what":"6 stop name(s) use abbreviations or symbols a screen reader may mispronounce, with no spoken form set (\"33rd Street - MedStar Union Memorial Hospital\", \"31st Street - Baltimore Museum of Art\", \"Woodall St\", and more).","why":"A screen reader speaks the raw name. 'Main St & 2nd Ave' can come out as 'Main saint', or lose the ampersand."}],"recompute":{"as_of":"2026-11-21","feed_fetched_date":"2026-11-09","kind":"freshness"},"routability":{"boardable_stops":106,"findings":[],"orphan_stops":0,"single_stop_trips":0,"trips_total":1096},"route_map":{"drawn_route_count":4,"has_shapes":true,"path":"data/artifacts/charm-city-circulator/geometry.geojson","route_count":4,"routes":[{"color":"8BC63E","color_name":"gray","has_shape":true,"id":"1","label":"Green","long":"Green","short":"","text_color":"FFFFFF","type_label":"Bus"},{"color":"F89D31","color_name":"orange","has_shape":true,"id":"2","label":"Orange","long":"Orange","short":"","text_color":"FFFFFF","type_label":"Bus"},{"color":"542989","color_name":"purple","has_shape":true,"id":"3","label":"Purple","long":"Purple","short":"","text_color":"FFFFFF","type_label":"Bus"},{"color":"1B496F","color_name":"green","has_shape":true,"id":"4","label":"Banner","long":"Banner","short":"","text_color":"FFFFFF","type_label":"Bus"}],"stop_count":106,"stop_points_capped":false},"rubric_version":"1.5","schema_version":"1.20","scoring_profile":{"id":"gtfs-scorecard-1.5","provenance":"GTFS Scorecard's project-authored weights, deductions, thresholds, grade bands, and fix ranking, informed by the California Transit Data Guidelines and the MobilityData gtfs-validator. It is not a worldwide standard or a compliance determination.","rubric_version":"1.5"},"shapes_readiness":{"detail":"All 1096 trips have a shape in shapes.txt.","status":"ready","total_trips":1096,"trips_with_shape":1096},"snapshot_date":"2026-11-21","top_fixes":[{"code":"scorecard_feed_expired","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"scorecard_feed_expired","line":"This one is about the feed as a whole, so there is no share of it to count.","reach":{"affected":null,"basis":"none","basis_label":null,"reason":"feed_level","share":null,"total":null,"total_source":null},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":1,"effort":"Usually one export setting; export on a schedule so it never lapses again.","fix":"Re-export the feed with a calendar that reaches further out. Set feed_end_date in feed_info.txt past your next service change.","owner":"Likely your export tool","points":100.0,"rank":1,"severity":"ERROR","what":"Service data ended 1727 day(s) ago.","why":"When the calendar runs out, trip planners stop showing this agency even though the buses are still running. Riders are told the service does not exist."},{"code":"scorecard_wheelchair_accessible_unknown","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"scorecard_wheelchair_accessible_unknown","line":"Fixing this covers all 1,096 trips in the feed.","reach":{"affected":1096,"basis":"trips","basis_label":"trips","reason":"","share":1.0,"total":1096,"total_source":"routability.trips_total"},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":1096,"effort":"A default or per-trip field in your export.","fix":"Set wheelchair_accessible on every trip. If every vehicle is accessible, this may be one default; otherwise use the value for each trip.","owner":"Likely your export tool","points":15.0,"rank":2,"severity":"WARNING","what":"1096 of 1096 trips don't say whether the vehicle is wheelchair accessible.","why":"Even with accessible stops, riders need to know the bus itself can take them."},{"code":"scorecard_no_fare_data","consequence":{"absences":["This feed carries no National Transit Database ID, so annual rider-trips are not known for it.","This record does not store transit need. The agency page and its reports add it from the need overlays and name their date."],"code":"scorecard_no_fare_data","line":"This one is about the feed as a whole, so there is no share of it to count.","reach":{"affected":null,"basis":"none","basis_label":null,"reason":"feed_level","share":null,"total":null,"total_source":null},"ridership":{"annual_rider_trips":null,"ntd_id":null,"reason":"no_ntd_id"},"served_area_need":{"reason":"not_joined_here","scale":"us_acs","tier":null}},"count":1,"effort":"A small file for most flat-fare systems.","fix":"Add fare_attributes.txt (or Fares v2 files) with your fare structure. If your service is fare-free, ask to have it marked fare-free instead.","owner":"","points":15.0,"rank":3,"severity":"WARNING","what":"The feed contains no fare information.","why":"Riders see 'fare unknown' in trip planners and can't budget their trip; visitors are most affected."}],"validator_version":"8.0.1"}